jReviews :: Customer support forum

The terminology you use is a bit confusing because I use it for jReviews but I think in a different context.

You can submit a product using custom fields and add an editorial review which includes both rating (criteria) and comments. I think the custom fields are what you refer to as criteria or product attributes.

A user can also submit product reviews allowing others to comment on it.

I think jReviews does what you want and it does have a lot of configuration settings which you may find useful once you start understanding them. If you are really considering purchasing it, then I encourage you to download the trial version and test it first hand.